Erza Scarlet vs Nami | Wisexier HMV

at the end the face and hair colour is the real difference because both have a hot big ass and hot big tits!!
a threesome with nami and erza would be so HOT!!!

Some parts maybe but cut apart since there was a lot to respond too but everything has been addressed.

Erza does not have more ass shots than Nami, not even close, literally just look up Erza ass and you'll see predominantly her in her big butt gang outfit with a few other shots here and there.




And with the better quality ones, no, in Zunesha and Wano Nami had better shots, as well as some cover arts by oda.

Well shape is more important than size anyway, unless you think those big butt gang guys from FT are better than Nami and Erza which is not the case for me and probably you, that's why someone like Zendaya has a better ass than a woman with a BBL.

I said Erza was larger but Nami has better shape, and no not even close on hips, ass is one thing (although Nami also handily takes ass) but hips are another, Erza was NEVER even that curvy, Juvia has more curves, Erza is just muscular.
Not to mention, Erza measurements also fluctuated, look at early FT (anime or manga) and then look at it now, everyone had that, especially Erza.
Size wise, Erza only takes tits, in every other regard, Nami is bigger and/or better shaped.



Nami is unique too face wise, just not so much in the anime with bad animation, even then there's a reason thier called NAMI clones.

As for your "bone structure" type of stuff, again no, Erza is pretty round features herself, especially before 100YQ, also, being able to cut a diamond in half with your sharp chin doesn't mean she has better structure in her face. At least Nami has a nose, sometimes FT girls have no nose are stub noses, Nami also has prettier eyes and better eye area shape. As for cheekbones and overall face, Nami has a blend of soft and round.

Soft and round features are actually more preferable for a lot of men, research the term neoteny, that's not to say angular jaw or featured women are less good looking, matter a fact, most of my favorite women in terms of looks in real life and fiction have sharper features but not to the point soft features are irrelevant.


Also, Nami in Zunesha arc alone looked like a goddess more than any FT girl ever did.


She is thicker in the manga but not as thick as Nami, you can see this in Zunsesha arc

Nah, Erza has a more droopy (not much) almost, pear like shape to her tits, Nami is rounder



This is actually where I'll disagree heavily, same face issue is only a problem with the anime, and the OP anime (especially preskip) was known for all around terrible animation for men and women, however when we control that variable for good to great animation, that's where you can see distinct faces, matter a fact, they are even more distinct in the manga.

It's a big issue in the community because the community are typical anime fans who think strong punch = good female character, so their output is not valid.


Not even close,  Erza is just as much an anime looking girl as Nami, Nami is just better designed. Even if we look at realistic drawn anime like Monster, we'd still freak out because they'd still be uncanny, there's not one animanga (besides ultra realistic ones) that wouldn't look uncanny in real life, it's the same logic for people who rub one out to xenomorphs but would run for the hills if they saw it in real life.


Well she's not a lot more detailed at all actually, look at official cover arts, there's a lot more details in Nami design than Erzas and OP is more detailed in general, FT is rather…more flat‽ idk. Also, like I said, the anime early into the timeskip was bad animation for everyone, now not so much. If we are talking about consistency then yes Erza is better but only better than early postskip Nami, but when we take both at their best, it's Nami all day.


I mean isn't she drunk in those episodes? And Natsu and Grey have a sister brother relationship dynamic so that's not really a fair comparison.



They aren't biased, I'm looking at it holistically, even you used the early  post skip anime (not the good animation parts or source material) for all of your rebuttals against Nami clearing Erza.


I'm not biased, Fairy Tail female cast are one of my top, it's just that One Piece female cast a Diff breed.

Erza has more ass shots than Nami as well as better quality ass shots and shape/roundness, plus from the Nami scenes I’ve seen her ass seems more toned than big.

Also as mandery said, Erza takes boobs by a pretty significant margin I’d say. Her calculated measurements are objectively larger than Nami’s. Even if we were to register both at their peaks, Erza’s are still larger. Including ass and hips related measurements.

You bring up inconsistency’s but that applies for both series. And as someone who has read and watch fairy tail, they are pretty consistent with how they depict their women considering how unlike one piece there are fan service shots every 4 minutes, thus allowing for less error for inconsistency since obviously they’re gonna make them look thicc af in these shots. Fairy Tail is well known for their curvy women just as much as one piece.

If we consider manga panels then this becomes even more of a losing battle because Erza is lowkey even thicc’er in the manga than she is in the anime imo.

Erza and Nami’s tit shape are pretty similar, they’re both round and whatever, anime isn’t really creative in tit shape.

Nami’s face is def hot but she shares that same face with so many others in her series to the point where same face syndrome is a big topic in the one piece community. Even if we were to disregard this, Nami would look somewhat uncanny irl because of her big eyes whereas Erza’s is a lot more normal. And if we were to consider anime-wise and not irl, Erza still takes since hers is a lot more detailed and unique, better bone structure, well proportioned nose and eyes, cheekbones etc in contrast to Nami’s softer jawline and more rounded features. She outright looks like a goddess in some scenes.

Nami is also pretty inconsistent. I don’t know if you’ve seen that infamous Robin shot where she had zero torso in the anime but it shows that One piece is far more inconsistent. Her measurements fluctuates from being slightly smaller or bigger. Also her proportion to her overall body can be a turnoff to some people whereas Erza is consistently drawn and has an excellent overall proportion to body.

Also I don’t agree with you saying that Erza is “uptight” with her body. There have been (many)episodes where she has been half naked or even just fully naked in front of several people. Men and women. She takes a bath with Natsu and grey and does not care. She fights half-naked all the time and dresses at times like a BDSM lady.

So saying that she’s uptight feels disingenuous.

Nami would be more so playful and adventurous in bed whereas Erza would be passionate and intense, with a strong and confident approach towards sex.

overall your whole arguments feel somewhat biased. Don’t get me wrong though, this is like a high diff(+) matchup.

Erza doesn't easily take tits, we can pull out measurements sure but let's be honest, are the animators or manga authors always consistent? If we take biggest panel or screenshot from manga or anime then it's still Nami but I digress since titty shape>>titty size, Nami is still in the same ballpark as Erza with better shape so Nami takes breast.

Breast were the only thing you could argue in Erza favor and that's only if we focus on measurements.

I don’t use much of canon lowkey. And also Ezra easily takes tits, when Erza was at that bar as a bunny her measurements were like 108 or something. I get what you are saying but I’m not that canon focused you get me?

Lover Erza but Nami takes everything and mid diffs, a good quality animation or Manga panel for both side by side and Nami takes it hands down and how does Erza get tits, wide hips, and ass? Erza has a few decent official ass pics and Nami wrecks there, especially post skip, and OP girls are literally known for breast, Nami and other OP girls are also known for how they are drawn which includes wide hips
Also, talking symmetry and harmony on animals characters is hilarious, every average anime character has that but Nami still has a better designed face.

Lastly, Erza is known for being "uptight" about her body, there's no reason to say she takes any sexual point over Nami Who life was dependent on her looks and also her ability to arouse men.